What the checker enforces
GRACE-lang.md has 22 rules that say the parser MUST reject something: the checker gates 12 of them, gates 5 in part, and only counts 5. This page was generated on 2026-11-14 from the grammar and the checker’s own codes; its date moves only when a row does. Nothing on it is hand-written.
Each row is one rule of the grammar, in its own words, the check that holds it, and one of three states:
- gates — a finding fails the public Lint run:
check.py --gateruns in that workflow beside the linter, so a finding of a gatingcheck.pycode, or of alint.pycode, turns the run red. - gates in part — one reading of the sentence gates, and another is read by nothing that gates; what slips through is listed under the table.
- only counted — the check is advisory or the normalizer’s: it is read and counted, and no run fails on it. This is the list of what is still owed.
| Rule | The grammar says | Held by | State |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surface 19 | The parser MUST reject a fenced block that carries a labelled rule under a first line that opens no normative block and no surface. | check.py F-fence-first |
gates |
| Hard invariant 1 | The parser MUST reject an unprefixed line in a normative block that does not parse. | check.py F-unlabelled, check.py F-fence-first |
gates |
| Hard invariant 2 | The parser MUST reject a normative rule with no explicit subject. | normalize.py N-unlowered |
only counted |
| Hard invariant 3 | The parser MUST reject a normative rule with no explicit modal where the statement shape requires one. | check.py R-no-modal |
gates |
| Hard invariant 4 | The parser MUST reject a normative rule carrying a pronoun. | check.py P-pronoun, check.py W-demonstrative |
gates in part |
| Hard invariant 5 | The parser MUST reject a normative sentence carrying two obligations. | check.py W-two-obligations |
only counted |
| Hard invariant 6 | The parser MUST reject a nested WHEN block. | check.py R-nested-when |
gates |
| Hard invariant 7 | The parser MUST reject a condition mixing AND and OR. |
check.py V-mixed |
gates |
| Hard invariant 8 | The parser MUST reject OR outside a condition or a term declaration. |
check.py V-or-obligation |
gates |
| Hard invariant 9 | The parser MUST reject BEFORE outside MUST NOT. |
check.py B-before |
gates in part |
| Hard invariant 10 | The parser MUST reject AFTER outside ONLY AFTER or the deterministic sugar. |
check.py B-after |
gates in part |
| Hard invariant 11 | The parser MUST reject a positive MUST … BEFORE ordering. |
check.py B-before |
gates in part |
| Hard invariant 13 | The parser MUST reject a cross-rule reference by ordinal. | normalize.py N-ordinal-ref |
only counted |
| Hard invariant 14 | The parser MUST reject a value used with EQUALS or DOES NOT EQUAL that is not blank and belongs to no declared closed value set. | normalize.py N-value-set |
only counted |
| Hard invariant 35 | The parser MUST reject an arithmetic operator in a definition outside the operator’s own pair of parentheses. | check.py A-decl-arith |
gates |
| Hard invariant 36 | The parser MUST reject a division outside a definition. | check.py A-arith, check.py D-rule-symbol, check.py A-decl-arith |
gates in part |
| Hard invariant 37 | The parser MUST reject a division whose definition names no rounding. | check.py A-decl-arith |
gates |
| Hard invariant 30 | The parser MUST reject a range citation whose last number does not follow the first number. | lint.py F-range-form |
gates |
| Hard invariant 31 | The parser MUST reject a run of labels written in a form other than the range citation. | lint.py F-range-form |
gates |
| Hard invariant 32 | The parser MUST reject NOT EXISTS. |
check.py D-condition-form |
gates |
| Hard invariant 34 | The parser MUST reject NOT EXCEEDS. |
check.py D-condition-form |
gates |
| Value set 2 | The parser MUST reject an undeclared value. | normalize.py N-value-set |
only counted |
What slips through
- Hard invariant 4 — it, its, itself, they, their, them, he, she, his and her gate; these and those alone are only counted, and this and that are not read.
- Hard invariant 9 — Only a
MUSTorMAYrule’sBEFOREis read; aBEFOREunderIS AUTHORITATIVE FOR, or in a condition, is not. - Hard invariant 10 — Only an
AFTERunderMUST NOTis read; anAFTERin a condition is not, and a lower-case one is only counted. - Hard invariant 11 — The pattern stops at a full stop, so a label or step number (
step 0.1a) before theBEFOREhides it. - Hard invariant 36 — A
/in a rule, and a division inside a parenthesized group, gate; a bare÷in a rule is read by nothing.
Nothing is gated and nothing is retired by this page: it is the list of what is owed.
The checks themselves are run by Verify It Yourself; the grammar is GRACE-lang.